Table 1

Characteristics of studies included in the systematic review.

s/noAuthor, (year)CountriesStudy periodType of MGTotal number of PatientsRecurrenceMean/Median Follow-up period (years)
1Palmisani, (1994)Italy1971-1991Thymoma11120>1
2Mano, (1993)JapanN/ABoth105509.8
3Ohmi, (1991)Japan1977 – 1989Both1663>1
4Abo Elnasr, (2016)Egypt2013-2015Non-thymoma3890.5
5Budde, (2001)USA1974-1999Both92234.3
6Meyer, (2009)USA1992-2006Both8136.0±4.0
7Masaoka, (1996)Japan1973 – 1993Both321471
8Bachmann, (2009)Germany1980 – 2005Non thymoma84239.8
9Maggi, (2008)Italy1986 - 2006Thymoma197627.69±6.0
10Venuta, (1999)Italy1970 – 1997Both204519.92
11Kaufman, (2016)USA1941-2013Both10026476
12Poomthong, (2012)Thailand2010Non thymoma51251
13Glinjongol, (2004)Thailand1990-2004Both3063.4
14Ozdemir, (2003)Turkey1990-2000Both61113.83
15Takanami, (2009)Japan1991-2005Both54186.0 ± 3.9
16Soleimani, (2004)Iran1985 - 2002Both110206.4 ± 4.3
171Nazarbaghi, (2015)Iran1999 - 2013Both250.57.3±4.2
18Kumar, (2011)India1991 - 2007Both73155.65
19De Roxas, (2016)Philippines2009 – 2014Both69271 year
20Frist, (1994)USA1971 – 1992Both4661
21Gao, (2016)China2010 – 2014Both130281.5
22Hsu, (2006)Taiwan1986 - 2001Both154621
23Kim, (2018 )South Korea1994 - 2016Both179141
24Muhammed, (2016)Malaysia2002 – 2012Both1621 year
25Mulder, (1989)USA1983 – 1987Both84173.6
26El-Medany, (2003)Saudi Arabia1986 – 2001Both100187.6
27Romi, (2003)Norway1973 - 2002Both48338.7
28Téllez-Zenteno, (2001)Mexico1987 – 1997Both132413
29Tsinzerling, (2007)Sweden1956 – 2006Both537881.5
30Werneck, (2000)Brazil1973 – 1995Both2826.3
31Yang, (2017)China2003 – 2013Non-thymoma123194.42
32Yu, (2015)China1984 – 2001Both297568.6
33Dube, (2017)India1993 – 2014Thymoma814.6
34Zheng, (2017)China2013 – 2016Both73162.2
35Lin, (2010)Taiwan1995 – 2004Non thymoma6093.7
36Bachmann, (2008)Germany1980 - 2005Both98178
37Nieto, (1999)Spain1977 – 1994Both6121
38Jaretzki, (1988)USA1997 – 1985Both9570.5
39Calhoun, (1999)USA1989 – 1998nonthymoma78125.0
40Shrager, (2002)USA1992 – 1999Both7884.6
41Detterbeck, (1996)USA1977 – 1993Both100225.4
42de Perrot, (2001)Switzerland1979 – 1999Both35268
43Tansel, (2003)Turkey1980 – 2001nonthymoma204207.2± 1.2
44Siwachat, (2018)Thailand`2006 – 2013Both98113.48
45Seyfari, (2018)Iran2011 – 2015Both4771
46Waitande, (2007)India1994 – 2003Both57172.4
47Kattach, (2006)United Kingdom1987 - 1998Both8534.5
48Huang, (2005)Taiwan1986 - 2000Both154188.2
49Hase, (2006)Japan1987 – 2001Both1740.5
50Remes-Troche, (2002)Mexico1989 – 2000Both152492
51Pompeo, (2009)Italy1995 – 20003Non thymoma3259.92
52Liu, (2016)China2000 - 2010Both31106.9
53Yu, (2014)China1997 – 2012Both188365.6
54Busch, (1996)Germany1976 - 1993Both86258.0
55Bril, (1998)Canada1977 – 1986Nonthymoma5258.4
56Klein, (1999)Germany1984 – 1992Both5173.9
57Mineo, (2000)Italy / Belgium1993 – 1997Both3113.3
58Zielinski, (2004)Poland2000 – 2003Nonthymoma4881
59Yim, (2002)Hong Kong1985– 2000Both3683.4
60Manlulu, (2005)China1992 – 2004Nonthymoma3635.8
61Savcenko, (2002)USA1992 – 2002Both3664.4
62Uchiyama, (2001)Japan1998 – 2000Both2321
63Wright, (2002)Australia1997 – 2001Nonthymoma2420.5
64Nussbaum, (2002)USA1979 – 1991Both4834.3
65Cooper, (1988)Canada1977 – 1986Both6533.5
66Olanow, (1987)Canada1979 – 1986Both5553.3
67DeFilippi, (1994)USA1977 - 1991Nonthymoma2144.3
68Mack, (1996)USA1992 – 1995Both3341.9
69Ambrogi, (2012)Italy1980 – 2005Nonthymoma962413.3
70Mineo, (2013)Italy1980 - 2007Nonthymoma4798.3
  • 1= no recurrence during follow-up, 0.5 was assigned to allow for meta-analysis; N/A = not available